What Does the Bruderhof Think about the Benedict Option?

March 16, 2017 by

The Benedict Option book cover

It’s proving to be an unsettling year. Words such as “crisis,” “resistance,” and “collapse” pepper headlines, and few dismiss them as mere alarmism. All is not well – on this, at least, there is broad consensus. The political cultures of Western countries are infested with rage. Cold War nightmares such as nuclear conflict are suddenly again imaginable. On the five-hundredth anniversary of the Reformation, Christian denominations – far from nearing a grand restoration of unity – find themselves riven by half-hidden schisms. Partisan divisions infect private life, hardening barriers and poisoning friendships.

At such a moment, being told to “take courage” can sound like a grim joke. No doubt that’s how it sounded to the friends of Jesus who accompanied him on his last journey to Jerusalem, where he would be killed. Yet, as John reports in the sixteenth chapter of his Gospel, “Take courage!” was one of the last things Jesus told his disciples, just hours before his arrest and execution. He added, in a statement that must have puzzled them: “I have overcome the world.”

Courage – heart, etymologically – seems to me precisely what we’re in need of today: courage to stand by the truth, and courage to stand by the gospel’s claim that everyone belongs to God, because Jesus has overcome the world. Such courage, according to Augustine, is simply a form of love – “love ready to bear all things for God’s sake.”

But as dangerous as the temptation is to become disheartened in a year like this, there is a danger more insidious still: the voice whispering that despite the suffering and degradation around us it’s not really that bad. This voice, of course, is far more likely to speak to the comfortable and affluent than to refugees, poor immigrants, the incarcerated, or the starving. It is also more likely to speak to those who believe that Christianity is doing just fine – that, setting aside a few inevitable shortcomings, we Christians have no urgent need to repent, certainly not in a way that would visibly transform our everyday lives.

A new book by Rod Dreher, The Benedict Option, has been garnering attention – and much of it amounts to a howl of protest against Dreher’s call for Christians to strategically retreat from seeking cultural power in order to build stronger Christian communities. Dreher’s various proposals can certainly be constructively criticized. But many reactions, it seems to me, altogether ignore his book’s basic insight: that Western churches, virtually across the board, have failed to cultivate faithful discipleship within a post-Christian culture. The symptoms of this failure are well documented, and damning. They include our ineffectiveness in passing the faith on to the next generation, as shown by sociologists such as Christian Smith; the extent to which materialism and consumerism – and militarism and nationalism – have polluted our everyday lives; divorce rates as high among Christians as among others; and an epidemic of pornography addiction afflicting Christian men.

In the face of these alarming facts, it is not enough to simply cry, “No withdrawal from culture!” while quoting the Great Commission. If we Christians do not show forth the justice and faithfulness of the kingdom of God in the way we live, why should anyone pay attention to our preaching? And isn’t it obvious that our response to these ills – or rather, our repentance for our sins – must include pouring far more energy into building church communities in which children are educated in the faith, mutual care is a priority, accountability to the church is really practiced, and economic sharing ensures that no brother or sister is in material need? That doesn’t sound like a retreat to me. It sounds like simply doing what the New Testament tells us to do: bear one another’s burdens, watch over one another’s souls, love one another.

We need courage, then, to see our Christianity with honest eyes – and to dare the tangible changes in our lives that the Spirit may then direct us to make. We’ll find this courage when we learn to see the world as God sees it. Jesus has overcome the world, and everyone in it belongs to him, even if many still resist him for the time being. This is the hope that Christoph F. Blumhardt points us to: hope for every human being and for all creation, because Jesus is victor:

The Savior is coming! This certainty is our joy; it is the source of our Christian life. Let it fill our days, today, tomorrow, and every day of our life.

Peter Mommsen is the editor of Plough Quarterly, from our Plough Publishing House. He appears regularly on our podcast, Bruderhof Talkfest. Check it out on SoundCloud, Google Play, Stitcher, and iTunes. He lives in the Fox Hill Bruderhof with his wife Wilma and their three children.

This post originally appeared in the Plough Quarterly. It has been edited for length.


Recommended Readings

View All

You Might Also Like

View All Articles
View All Articles